The money myths we still believe, Part 1: ten myths about saving, investing and getting started


Most of us learned about money the way we learned about cricket, from family, friends, and whatever was being said around us. Some of that wisdom held up well. A lot of it was formed in a different India, with different interest rates, different products, and very different access to markets. The result is a set of money beliefs that sound sensible, get repeated at every family gathering, and quietly shape how people save, invest and build wealth.
This is the first of a two-part series on the money myths we still believe. In Part 1, we look at ten myths about starting out, fixed deposits, the stock market, timing, SIPs, mutual fund mechanics, gold and property. For each one, we ask what the myth gets right, where it breaks down, and what the Indian data actually say. The aim is not to sell you a product or tell you that markets are always kind. It is to replace a comforting story with a more useful one.
Why do money myths survive even when the data contradicts them?
Money myths survive because they are usually half true. Fixed deposits really are stable in nominal terms. Markets really do fall sharply from time to time. Gold really has protected wealth in some periods. The myth takes a true fragment and stretches it into a rule that stops working when conditions change.
They also survive because they cost nothing to believe in the short run. Waiting for a better entry point feels prudent. Keeping everything in a deposit feels safe. The cost of these choices shows up slowly, over years, and rarely gets traced back to the belief that caused it. A myth that costs you a little every year, without ever sending a bill, is the hardest kind to unlearn.
Myth 1: Do you need a lot of money to start investing?
The belief is that investing is for people with surplus cash, and that small amounts are not worth the trouble. So people wait for a bigger salary, a bonus, or the day the loan is cleared.
The facts point the other way. AMFI, the mutual fund industry body, lists "you need a large amount to invest" among the myths it addresses on its investor education page, and notes that a SIP can start from as little as ₹500 a month. Individual fund houses set their own minimums, and some accept even less, so check the scheme you are considering. What matters more than the minimum is the habit and the time.
Here is a simple illustration. These numbers are our own assumptions, not forecasts or promises. Assume a long-term return of 12% a year and a SIP that runs for 30 years. A ₹500 monthly SIP would grow to roughly ₹15.4 lakh, on a total investment of ₹1.8 lakh. A ₹1,000 monthly SIP would grow to roughly ₹30.8 lakh, and ₹5,000 a month to roughly ₹1.54 crore. Real returns will be different, and some years will be negative, but the pattern is clear: the amount you start with matters less than how early you start and how long you stay.
The real risk of waiting for "enough" money is that you lose the years. Starting small and raising the amount as your income grows - a step-up approach - usually beats waiting for a large starting sum that never feels ready.
Myth 2: Are fixed deposits risk-free, and the best way to grow wealth?
Fixed deposits deserve their reputation for stability. The principal and the promised interest are predictable, and for emergency money and near-term goals, that predictability is exactly the point. The myth begins when FDs are treated as risk-free in every sense, and as a wealth-building tool for long goals.
The risk that FDs do not remove is the loss of purchasing power. Consider the numbers as they stand. According to a report by the Morung Express citing government data, retail inflation (CPI) in September 2026 was 5.54%, up from 4.83% in August, with food inflation at 7.74%. Meanwhile, HDFC Bank's general-customer FD rate was 6.25% for one year and 6.60% for three to five years, as reported by Upstox for rates effective 4 November 2026. SBI's published table, as captured by BankBazaar, showed 6.25% for one to two years and 6.30% for three to five years, though that table is dated December 2025 and may have been revised since. Some small finance banks advertise higher rates, with Suryoday at up to 8.25% for general customers, but those banks carry a different credit profile from the large banks, so the extra rate should be weighed against the extra risk before you commit.
Now add tax. FD interest is taxed at your income tax slab rate. Here is our own illustration, with assumptions stated. Suppose you earn 6.5% on an FD and you are in the 30% slab. After tax, ignoring cess and surcharge, you keep about 4.55%. If inflation runs at 5.54%, your real, after-tax return is about minus 1% a year. Your balance grows, but what it can buy shrinks. For someone in a lower slab, the arithmetic is kinder, but the direction of the problem is the same whenever inflation is close to or above the post-tax rate.
Inflation numbers move from month to month, and a few months of high food prices do not define the next ten years. The point is not that FDs are bad. It is that they do one job well, protecting capital and providing certainty, and they are not designed to be the engine of long-term wealth. A sensible plan usually gives each job its own tool: FDs or similar safe instruments for emergency money and goals within a few years, and growth assets for goals that are many years away.
Myth 3: Is the stock market just gambling?
This myth has a real basis, and it is worth being fair to it. SEBI's study of equity derivatives trading for FY25, as reported by Business Standard, found that nearly 91% of individual F&O traders made net losses, with their aggregate net loss rising to ₹1,05,603 crore from ₹74,812 crore in FY24 after accounting for transaction costs. The study covered the top 13 brokers and around 96 lakh unique traders. If your picture of "the market" is short-term derivatives trading, calling it gambling is understandable.
But that is trading, not investing. Investing in equity through a diversified fund means owning a slice of businesses that earn profits, pay wages, and grow over time. Gambling is a zero-sum bet on an outcome you cannot influence. A business owner is not gambling when the business grows. The difference is the time horizon, the instrument, and the behaviour.
None of this means equities are safe. They are not. The Nifty 50 Total Returns Index fell 50.2% from its peak after the 2000 dotcom bubble, more than 55% in the 2008 global financial crisis, and 38.3% during Covid, according to the FundsIndia analysis reported by Business Standard and Outlook Money. Over a single year, the Nifty has ended lower roughly one year in four, according to INDmoney's calculation on the price index from 1990 to 2024. Over longer horizons, the record improves a lot. The same Outlook Money piece, citing FundsIndia data on the Nifty 50 TRI, reports that only about 6% of rolling three-year periods were negative and that no seven-year period since the index began in June 1999 was negative. INDmoney's price-index data shows a similar picture, with almost no negative ten-year windows once the 1990s are excluded.
These are historical patterns on one index with limited independent data, not guarantees. The sensible reading is neither "markets are gambling" nor "markets always win". It is that equity returns are uncertain in the short run, reasonably rewarding over long periods, and that your behaviour decides whether you capture them.
Myth 4: Should you wait for the right time, or for the market to fall, before investing?
This is probably the most expensive myth in personal finance, because it feels so reasonable. If the market is high, wait. If it has just fallen, wait for it to fall more. The "right time" never quite arrives, and meanwhile the money sits idle.
There are three pieces of evidence worth knowing. The first is what happens when you miss the best days. ShareIndia, citing an Abakkus Mutual Fund analysis of the Nifty 50 TRI from April 2005 to July 2026, reports that a fully invested investor saw their money grow 15.4 times, a CAGR of 13.67%. Missing just the five best days cut that to 9.8 times (11.31% CAGR), and missing the ten best days cut it to 7.3 times (9.75% CAGR). The page itself notes that this is a hypothetical, since real investors rarely miss exactly the best days. A separate FundsIndia analysis reported by Business Standard found that ₹10 lakh invested in the Nifty 50 TRI from 2005 to 2025 grew to ₹1.43 crore, but only ₹67 lakh if the ten best days were missed.
The second piece is that the best days tend to sit close to the worst. In the same Business Standard report, 22 of the top 30 best days since 2005 fell during the 2008 crash, and the day after the March 2020 bottom was one of the best days of all, with the index up 8.8% on 7 April 2020, according to the report. If you step out when things feel frightening, you are likely to be out when the sharpest recoveries happen.
The third is what happens when you buy at a record high. FundsIndia's analysis of the Nifty 50 TRI, covering more than 24 years of all-time highs, found that the five-year return after buying at an all-time high was positive every time, and the average one-year return was about 14%. Even investors who bought right before major falls did well if they stayed. According to the Business Standard report, someone who invested at the 2000 peak and held to March 2025 earned about 12% a year, and according to Outlook Money, someone who bought at the January 2020 peak earned about 15% a year to October 2025.
Please read these with care. All of these analyses draw on the same family of FundsIndia research, so they are not independent confirmations, and FundsIndia is a distributor with its own view. The data are for a short history, up to 2023 or 2025 depending on the study, and past patterns do not promise future ones. The takeaway is not "invest everything at once without thinking". It is that waiting for a perfect entry has a measurable cost, and that a regular, rule-based approach, such as a SIP or a staggered plan for a lump sum, removes the need to guess.
Myth 5: Does a SIP guarantee returns, or only work when markets are rising?
Two opposite myths grow around the SIP. One says a SIP is a safe, assured product. The other says a SIP only makes sense when markets are going up. Both are wrong.
A SIP is a method of investing, not a product, and it carries the same market risk as the fund it invests in. Mutual fund schemes are not guaranteed or assured return products, and the standard market-risk disclosure on every scheme says units can lose value. A SIP does not protect you from a falling market. If the fund declines and stays down for the entire time you invest, you can end up with less than you put in.
What a SIP does do is take the timing decision away. Because a fixed amount buys more units when prices are low and fewer when prices are high, falling markets are not a problem for a long-term SIP investor. They are the phase when the same rupee buys more. The danger is behavioural. AMFI data for September 2026, as reported by Angel One, put the SIP stoppage ratio at 78.53%, and monthly SIP contributions hit a record ₹32,490 crore with over ten crore contributing accounts, according to 5paisa's report. The stoppage ratio compares SIPs that were stopped or matured with new SIPs registered in a month, so it does not mean 78% of investors quit. It does show how much churn there is. Investors who stop their SIP during a fall give up the cheaper units and lock in the discomfort.
A good SIP discipline has three parts: pick a fund that matches your horizon and risk, raise the amount as your income grows, and keep going through the bad phases, which are where much of the long-term benefit comes from.
Myth 6: Will last year's top-performing fund keep winning?
Every January, lists of last year's best funds do the rounds, and money follows them. The belief is that a fund which topped the charts is somehow better managed and will do it again.
The data do not support this. The S&P SPIVA India scorecard for year-end 2025 offers a striking example. Over one year, only 12.07% of Indian mid and small-cap funds underperformed their benchmark, which S&P described as the best result for that category in a decade. Yet over three years the underperformance share was 41.51%, over five years 46.00%, and over ten years 79.03%. For large-cap funds, 75.00% underperformed over one year, 74.19% over three years, 84.38% over five years, and 76.29% over ten years. S&P also noted that a firm majority of funds in every category underperformed over the decade ending December 2025.
The scorecard does not directly measure whether top performers stay on top, so we should not claim it proves they do not. What it shows is that one year of results, even an excellent year, tells you very little about the next ten. It also uses the whole fund universe in its calculations, so funds that were merged or closed count as underperformers rather than disappearing from the record.
There is a second cost to chasing performance. AMFI's investor education page lists "buying a top-rated scheme ensures better returns" as a myth, noting that ratings change over time and that past performance does not necessarily guarantee future returns. The practical problem is timing. Money that moves into last year's winner usually arrives after much of the gain has already happened, and it often leaves after a weak year, which turns a fund's return into a lower return for the investor. That is a point of logic rather than a measured statistic for India, but it is a pattern many advisers will recognise from their client files.
None of this means you should avoid active funds or pick a particular style. It means a fund should be judged on cost, process, consistency over a full market cycle and fit with your goal, not on one year's rank.
Myth 7: Does a low NAV mean a mutual fund is cheap?
A fund with a NAV of ₹15 looks cheaper than one at ₹150. It feels like buying a stock at a lower price per share. It is not.
AMFI addresses this directly on its myth page, saying NAV is the market value of the fund's holdings per unit, and that the current NAV does not affect the returns you earn. Tata Mutual Fund offers a clean example. Take two schemes with identical portfolios, one with a NAV of ₹10 and one of ₹100. If you put ₹10,000 into each, you receive 1,000 units of the first and 100 units of the second. If both portfolios rise 10%, the first NAV goes to ₹11 and the second to ₹110. Both of your holdings are now worth ₹11,000. The lower NAV gave no advantage.
A fund's NAV is mostly a result of when it launched and how long it has run. A high NAV often reflects years of growth, not an expensive fund. What you should compare is the portfolio, the cost (expense ratio), the risk, and the track record over a full cycle. The NAV is the least useful number on the page.
Myth 8: Do more funds mean more diversification?
Many portfolios we see have fifteen or twenty funds, built up over years through advisers, friends' tips and last year's rankings. The belief is that more funds means more safety. Diversification, however, is about holding different sources of risk and return, not about holding a larger number of products.
If five of your funds are large-cap or flexi-cap funds with similar top holdings, you own the same companies five times, with five sets of statements to track and five expense ratios to pay. The portfolio looks varied but behaves like one. The reverse also holds: a handful of well-chosen funds across equity, debt and perhaps gold can cover the ground that matters.
There is also a practical cost. Too many funds make it harder to see your actual asset allocation, to rebalance, to review performance and to remember why you bought each one. A useful test is to look at what each fund does for you that the others do not. If you cannot answer in one sentence, that fund may be overlapping. Checking the overlap in holdings between funds is a sensible habit before adding another one.
Myth 9: Is the dividend from a mutual fund free income?
Under the IDCW option (Income Distribution cum Capital Withdrawal, the name SEBI gave to the dividend option from 1 April 2021), a fund pays out money at intervals. Many investors read this as the fund "giving" them income on top of their investment, with the original amount still intact.
The mechanics tell a different story. Tata Mutual Fund explains it with an example. A scheme has net assets of ₹10 lakh, 50,000 units, and a NAV of ₹20. You invest ₹20,000 and get 1,000 units. The scheme declares an IDCW of ₹2 per unit. The payout of ₹1 lakh leaves the scheme, so net assets fall to ₹9 lakh, and the NAV drops from ₹20 to ₹18. Your 1,000 units are now worth ₹18,000, and you received ₹2,000. The total is still ₹20,000. As Tata puts it, the payout creates no additional wealth. You were paid a part of your own money.
Three more points matter. IDCW is not guaranteed, since the fund house decides whether to declare it and how much, and the payout can come from income, realised gains, or from the investor's own capital. IDCW is also taxed. As per Outlook Money's explainer, after the Finance Act 2020, these payouts are added to your total income and taxed at your slab rate, with TDS applying above a threshold, so check the current limit. And with the growth option, you pay capital gains tax only when you redeem, which often leaves more of your money compounding in the meantime.
If you want regular cash flow, a planned withdrawal from a growth option or a systematic withdrawal plan is usually clearer about what you are doing, because you decide how much to take and you can see that it is your capital being used. The right choice depends on your tax position and need, which is worth discussing with an adviser.
Myth 10: Do gold and property never fall?
Gold and real estate hold a special place in Indian households. The belief is that they only go up, and that they are the safest stores of value. The recent run in gold prices has strengthened this belief.
Gold's own history in India is less one-directional. According to the Aditya Birla Capital gold price table, the average 24K price was ₹29,926 per 10 grams in 2012, ₹28,848 in 2013 (down 3.6%), ₹27,708 in 2014 (down 4.0%) and ₹26,671 in 2015 (down 3.7%). That is three annual falls in a row, a total of about 10.9% by our arithmetic. Using the same table, the 2018 average of ₹30,692 was only about 2.6% above 2012, which works out to around 0.4% a year over six years, again, our own calculation. Capitalmind's long-history analysis notes that in rupee terms gold has not had a negative decade, which helps explain why Indian households trust it as a store of value. Even so, gold can go sideways for years, as the 2012 to 2018 period shows, and it pays no interest or dividend. It works best as a diversifier in a portfolio, not as a guaranteed winner.
Property has its own version of this. The RBI's House Price Index, covering 18 cities, rose 4.2% year on year in Q4 FY26 (January to March 2026), as reported by Outlook Business citing PTI. For Q1 FY26, the figure was 3.6%, and Policy Edge reports the year-earlier quarter at 7.6%. Price growth across an index can slow considerably within a year, and it varies widely by city and locality. Those headline figures also do not capture the things that matter to an individual buyer, such as stamp duty and registration, maintenance, vacancy, the difficulty of selling quickly, or the rental yield.
Both assets can have a place in a portfolio. The myth is the word "never". The questions to ask are how much of your wealth sits in a single asset, how easily you could sell it if you needed to, and whether you are holding it for a reason or only because everyone does.
How can you tell a money myth from a money fact?
A few habits help. Ask whether the claim is true in all conditions or only in some. Look for the time period and the index or product behind any statistic, since a number without a date or a benchmark is easy to bend. Check whether the person repeating it earns something when you believe it, which is true of distributors, platforms, and sometimes advisers, and does not automatically make them wrong, but does tell you to cross-check. And notice whether the advice would still make sense if markets did the opposite of what you expect.
Most of all, treat any statement that contains the words "always", "never", "guaranteed" or "risk-free" with suspicion. Real financial decisions involve trade-offs, and a good plan tells you what you are giving up, not only what you are getting.
What is coming in Part 2?
Part 1 dealt with myths about starting out, saving and market behaviour. Part 2 looks at the myths that shape protection, tax, debt and planning: whether debt funds can lose money, whether insurance is an investment, whether tax saving is the same as investing, whether you are too young or too old to plan, whether EPF alone is enough for retirement, and whether paying off every loan early is always wise.
At BYLD Wealth, we are a SEBI-registered, commission-free advisory firm, and we believe that better financial decisions start with clearer information and a plan built around your own goals. If any of these myths have been shaping your decisions, you can follow our work at BYLD Wealth on LinkedIn and speak with us about building a plan that fits your situation.
This post is for general educational purposes and should not be construed as investment advice, a recommendation to buy or sell any security, or tax or legal advice. All investments are subject to market risks, and past performance may or may not be sustained in the future. Illustrations in this post use assumed returns for explanation only and are not forecasts. Please consult a SEBI-registered investment adviser or a qualified tax professional before acting on any of this.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the biggest money myth Indian investors believe?
The most costly one is probably that you must wait for the right time to invest. It feels prudent, but the data we reviewed show that missing even a handful of the best market days cut long-term returns sharply, and those days often arrive close to the worst ones. A regular SIP or a staggered plan removes the need to guess.
Are fixed deposits really unsafe because of inflation?
Fixed deposits are not unsafe in the sense of losing your principal with a well-regulated bank, but their after-tax return can fall below inflation. With CPI at 5.54% in September 2026 and large-bank FD rates around 6.25% to 6.60%, a person in the 30% slab could see a negative real return. FDs suit short-term and emergency money better than long-term growth.
Is it better to wait for a market crash before investing?
Usually not. Crashes are hard to predict, and the strong recovery days tend to cluster near the worst days, so waiting can mean missing them. Historical Nifty 50 TRI analyses show that even buyers at all-time highs or just before large falls did well if they stayed invested for years, though past patterns are not guarantees.
Can a SIP lose money?
Yes. A SIP invests in market-linked funds and carries the same risk as the fund itself. If the fund falls and stays down over your whole investment period, you can end up with less than you put in. A SIP reduces the timing risk, not the market risk, and it works best when continued for many years.
How much should I invest per month to start?
There is no single right number. AMFI notes that a SIP can start from ₹500 a month, and many investors begin small and raise the amount every year as income grows. A better question is how much you can invest consistently without disturbing your emergency fund and essential expenses, and for which goal.
Does a low NAV mean a mutual fund is cheaper?
No. NAV is the per-unit value of a fund's holdings, and it reflects mostly when the fund launched and how long it has run. If two funds have identical portfolios and both rise 10%, your money grows 10% in either, whatever the NAV. Compare the portfolio, costs, risk and track record instead.
Is the IDCW option good for regular income?
Not automatically. An IDCW payout is a part of the fund's assets handed back to you, and the NAV falls after it is paid, so it is not additional return. It is also not guaranteed and is taxed at your slab rate. A planned withdrawal from a growth option can give you more control and clarity.
Is investing in the stock market the same as gambling?
No, but trading can resemble it. SEBI's FY25 study found that nearly 91% of individual F&O traders made net losses. Investing in diversified equity funds over many years means owning businesses that earn profits. Equities can still fall sharply in the short run, so the horizon and your behaviour matter.
Should I buy last year's best-performing fund?
A single year of top performance is a weak guide. In the SPIVA India year-end 2025 data, only 12.07% of mid and small-cap funds underperformed over one year, yet 79.03% underperformed over ten years. Judge funds on cost, process, consistency across a full market cycle and fit with your goals.
Is gold or real estate completely safe?
No asset is. Gold prices in India fell three years in a row from 2013 to 2015 and were roughly flat between 2012 and 2018 on average annual prices. Real estate indices can slow sharply, and property is hard to sell quickly. Both can play a role in a portfolio, but concentration in one asset is the real risk.






